Sometimes these questions are asked in a larger forum, on TV or in news articles and often unschooling is looked at with scrutiny, and more unfortunately, with prejudice. This is why many families are hesitant to talk to the media, and simply because, how does one convey an entire philosophy of living, parenting and being present in a few sentences or minutes? It's not easy, and the risk is always there for misunderstanding and misrepresentation. It takes an entire paradigm shift, in one's thinking, understanding and living, and it's a shift that is required just about every waking moment of unschoolers and unschooling parents; it is perhaps unreasonable to expect that media should grasp the philosophy, having only grappled with it for the brief length of an interview.
There are other risks associated with speaking publicly about unschooling, (beyond any privacy risks) as well. Should any one family be the spokesperson for unschooling, when unschooling certainly has key principles, to the world, it can look very different from family to family? Currently (always), there is an ongoing discussion in the unschooling community about unschooling philosophy and its principles, who decides those principles and are some people adhering to unschooling more appropriately (if appropriate applies, even) than others. As such, there's a certain wariness and responsibility many unschoolers feel when speaking openly about our learning philosophy.
This is not to say that there are never positive, informative and affirming ways in which to discuss unschooling openly. Many have written and published books that have gone on to be cornerstones to unschooling philosophy. There are numerous, amazing blogs that chronicle the lives of unschooling people. Many unschoolers produce videos for YouTube or present and conferences or other forums regarding their experiences. Last week (September 5, 2011) Olivia, 14, produced and co-hosted a show on unschooling for WMPG's Blunt Youth Radio. Her intent was to present unschooling without debate and without contrasting it to school and to present unschooling to the greater community, as an Unschooling 101. During the program, Olivia's co-host asked her some questions about her own unschooling experience and later, they interviewed several people, in-studio and via the phone, including yours truly. Marieke, lives locally and so she was in-studio. As a grown, always-unschooler who recently just earned her Masters degree, she offered her own fascinating and unique perspective on her unschooling, and she remains a steadfast supporter of the philosophy. Olivia also interviewed Kathryn Baptista, the founder and organizer of the Northeast Unschooling Conference and the mother of grown unschooler and musician, Julian Baptista. The show, I think, was very successful and stayed true to Olivia's goal and intent with presenting unschooling. (I wish that I could link you to the archived recording, but it is unavailable at this time. I will see what I can do to remedy this.)
Sometimes, too, people in the media are truly interested in the unschooling philosophy and seek out those families willing to share their experiences and are invited to do so without being antagonized or misrepresented by the interviewer, as was the case at the end of last week, when the local paper interviewed our family. The author, Gillian Graham, came to our home and sat with us around our table for over an hour, listening mostly, to our rather enthusiastic and probably overwhelming perspectives on unschooling. We are grateful to her for her willingness to listen and report on a topic so dear to us. Similarly, this report offered up a fair look at unschooling, just as most education articles were focused on back-to-school topics.
While it's not always easy to discern who is going to be open-minded enough to report on unschooling without bias, I think it's important for unschoolers to keep trying. While negative and hostile comments and reactions from our own circle of family and friends, communities, institutions and media can drive us to isolation or only willing to seek out the company of other unschoolers, there are people out there willing and ready to learn from unschooling. I see increasing evidence that unschooling philosophy (knowingly or not) is being looked to, when news pieces on education reform talk about adoption of technology in the classroom,
"Kids, especially in kindergarten, who are five years old, are very hands on and learn best when they're actually manipulating information and manipulating objects,"says Sherwood Heights principal Laura Shaw. She says iPads also provide children with immediate feedback."
or how classrooms are using resources long used by unschoolers to help students learn.
"Initially, Thordarson thought Khan Academy would merely be a helpful supplement to her normal instruction. But it quickly become far more than that. She’s now on her way to “flipping” the way her class works. This involves replacing some of her lectures with Khan’s videos, which students can watch at home. Then, in class, they focus on working problem sets. The idea is to invert the normal rhythms of school, so that lectures are viewed on the kids’ own time and homework is done at school. It sounds weird, Thordarson admits, but this flipping makes sense when you think about it. It’s when they’re doing homework that students are really grappling with a subject and are most likely to need someone to talk to. And now Thordarson can tell just when this grappling occurs: Khan Academy provides teachers with a dashboard application that lets her see the instant a student gets stuck."
More telling is that education reformers have begun using the very language and actual principles of unschooling, as in this Daily Riff article,
"Since the role of the teacher has changed, to more of a tutor than a deliverer of content, we have the privilege of observing students interact with each other. As we roam around the class, we notice the students developing their own collaborative groups. Students are helping each other learn instead of relying on the teacher as the sole disseminator of knowledge. It truly is magical to observe. We are often in awe of how well our students work together and learn from each other."
Then there are the popular bloggers, like Seth Godin, who question the very existence of school as we currently know it and challenge us all to do the hard work of questioning school, too.
Perhaps as the very schools we unschoolers choose to do without adopt more and more unschooling principles, the questions we get from the clerk at the grocery store will become less critical, and more curious. Perhaps the parks and museums will become learning hubs once more, as the classroom walls expand outward, into the world. We can continue unschooling, adding our voices and principles to the education discussion, as we become less reticent to do so as the system changes. We can hope.
This is why I won't do a public interview, you just get misrepresented. I don't want my privacy invaded like that.ReplyDelete
I do blog and write articles and talk with those that are interested so that is how I spread the word of unschooling.
I've been wondering about all this media attention, I understand (not agree) why Unschooling gets a bad wrap, it goes against everything mainstream education is about, it isn't a tweaking of the system in schools. What I wonder is if the conversation was to come from the more general consensual parenting what the response would be? [though as I write this I can see a lot of people just calling the kids spoiled without really looking at the root of consensual.]ReplyDelete
I understand the desire and need to be guarded, Stephanie. I also see the need for speaking openly about unschooling, (from those willing, of course--I agree that not everyone needs or can be the be poster children for unschooling)as I see that as a way of normalizing and helping others learn about unschooling. I have met several people who told me later that I was the first person they ever heard speak about unschooling, for instance, and that's why I don't see it as an invasion of privacy (conditions may apply).ReplyDelete
echolage, hmm, interesting point, though, as you mentioned, given the backlash and lumping together of consensual or attachment parents with those "unparents" or "hover parents" or "permissive parents", I'm not sure the message would be heard any differently.
Thank you for reading and commenting, both. xo
Great post. I've noticed that weird lack of kids, now that school is in full swing. It's depressing; like they've all been stolen. My kids never seem to notice that they are the only ones in the store, but I always do. Guess I'm too conditioned not to!ReplyDelete
New to your blog. We homeschool, but I wouldn't qualify as unschoolers. I think for all of us, homeschoolers and unschoolers alike--as educational choice widens and we go different routes--our children will age, enter society as amazing adults, and be our best ambassadors. I agree it's important to normalize the choice and expand the public perception of what education means and can be, by being vocal yourself. But I also anxiously await the day when our children can carry the message more powerfully than we can, through their obvious sheer awesomeness as adult members of society.ReplyDelete
I'm 37 and homeschooled people my age are exceedingly rare, but I don't think that will be the case for my children when they're adults. Their numbers are growing too quickly.